Pizza and an amber cocktail on a walnut restaurant table beside a softly lit window on a November evening.

The Old Natalie's Building on North High Is Open on Both Floors Again

"Thank you for loving and accepting our weird; it's been an absolute pleasure serving you for the past 5 and a half years." That was the goodbye from The Light of Seven Matchsticks, the speakeasy under Natalie's Worthington, in a social media post that Columbus Underground reported in September 2022. The bar closed after service on Sunday, September 18 of that year. Natalie's had shows booked in Worthington only through that September.

With Thanksgiving a week away, both floors of 5601 N. High St. are open again. Fired Up Pizza is in the main-floor space where Natalie's served coal-fired pies and booked live music. The Nine, a cocktail bar with a full food menu, is in the basement room that held Matchsticks. The two businesses opened within a few weeks of each other last spring. What's changed since then is the hours. Fired Up now stays open into the evening, so for a few hours five nights a week you can eat dinner upstairs and then walk down for a drink, the same way Natalie's and Matchsticks used to work together.

What the building was before

Natalie's Worthington celebrated ten years of live music and coal-fired pizza in the summer of 2022. Matchsticks opened downstairs in early 2017 and, according to Columbus Underground, was consistently voted one of the top bars in Columbus by that site's readers. Looking back this March, 614Now recalled that before 2022 there was a wait to get into that basement bar on any given weekend night.

In September 2022, owner Charlie Jackson listed both spaces for sale together as a "package deal," with an asking price of $219,000, as 614Now reported at the time. The listing said the owners were "concentrating on a larger venue located in different area of Columbus." That venue is Natalie's Grandview, which opened in December 2019 in the former King Avenue 5 space. It has nearly three times the room of the Worthington original and two stages, and it still books shows. If you followed a band from High Street to King Avenue, they're still playing there.

According to the Columbus Dispatch, Natalie's ran in the Worthington space for 11 years, and the most recent tenant before Fired Up was the Afro-Caribbean restaurant Sahara Lux. In January 2026, the City of Worthington posted a Board of Zoning Appeals notice about a sign variance for Fired Up at 5601 N. High St. That notice also confirms the building is inside the city.

Upstairs: Fired Up Pizza, a counter with a market case

Fired Up Pizza is owned by Michael Rice, a former Cameron Mitchell Restaurants executive chef. In a post that 614Now reported on November 11, the Worthington Chamber of Commerce congratulated "Michael and Shannon and the entire Fired Up team." The business started as a catering service and also sells frozen pizzas in Central Ohio grocery stores. The same Chamber post, as 614Now quoted it, said: "What started as a mobile pizza kitchen and farmers market favorite now has its first brick-and-mortar home on High Street." If you've bought a pie from them at a market stall, this is the same pizza in a permanent home.

The Columbus Dispatch reported a grand-opening weekend of March 27 to 29. The Chamber's official ribbon cutting followed much later, on Thursday, November 5.

If you remember Natalie's, the room won't look familiar. Breakfast With Nick described long counters at the entrance, with the team building pies and sliding them into the oven where you can watch. The dining tables are off to the far right. The menu on Fired Up's site lists wood-fired pizzas including the Margherita, Peppe and Giordano, along with spaghetti and meatballs, Italian sandwiches, pasta, desserts, and deli meats and cheeses. The Giordano has red sauce, mozzarella, basil, crumbled meatball and ricotta. The same review calls the sandwiches "giant" and notes that the cannoli are filled to order.

The market case is the part to know about this week. In a late-2025 interview that 614Now quoted in March, Rice described the plan as "more of a deli and market kind of feel," with "deli cases with prepared Italian foods, like lasagna, manicotti, meatballs sausages, fresh pastas, sauces and Italian meats and cheeses." A pan of lasagna or a bag of fresh pasta and sauce is an easy dinner to bring home on the Friday after Thanksgiving, once the leftovers run out and the house is still full.

Downstairs: The Nine, in the old Matchsticks room

The Nine is owned by Bismaark Akomeah, formerly a mixologist at High Bank Distillery Co. It opened to the public on March 10, according to 614Now. The Nine's own site lists its address as 5597 N. High St. It's the same building, with the lower-level entrance under its own number.

Breakfast With Nick described the room as "a little more modern but still cozy" compared with the "delightfully kitschy" Matchsticks. The menu is the bigger change. Matchsticks was known for its cocktails. The Nine serves a full menu of Mediterranean-leaning shareables. 614Now's opening coverage listed braised short rib, a spicy feta dip and quartered chicken. By August, Breakfast With Nick's review of the updated menu covered spicy feta with warm naan, a Mediterranean cornbread with sun-dried tomatoes and burnt honey, empanadas, cacio e pepe and tuna crudo.

The cocktail list is designed like a composition notebook and built around 1990s nostalgia. The Cartoons and Cereal mixes cereal milk-washed rum with mango, amaretto and vanilla. The Reading Rainbows uses Watershed Distillery's barrel-aged gin and comes with a scoop of sorbet. On the opening menu, 614Now highlighted Whisper of Tomorrow, with basil vermouth, pomegranate and coconut, and Model Village, with brown butter, sage, overripe bananas and whiskey.

The Nine doesn't take reservations. "We welcome guests on a first come, first served basis," reads its visit page. For a holiday-weekend group, the earlier you arrive, the better your odds of a table.

Why the hours matter more than the menus

When Fired Up opened in March, it posted hours of Tuesday through Saturday, 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. The Nine opens at 4 p.m. In spring, the overlap was a short late-afternoon window, so pizza upstairs and drinks downstairs meant eating dinner early.

Fired Up's current hours, published by 614Now on November 11, run to 8 p.m. Tuesday through Thursday and to 9 p.m. on Friday and Saturday. Fired Up's site lists it as closed Sunday and Monday. The Nine's hours below are the ones Breakfast With Nick printed in August.

Day Fired Up Pizza, upstairs The Nine, downstairs Both open
Tuesday to Thursday 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. 4 to 11 p.m. 4 to 8 p.m.
Friday and Saturday 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. 4 p.m. to midnight 4 to 9 p.m.
Sunday Closed From 5 p.m. None
Monday Closed No hours listed None

Friday and Saturday give you a five-hour overlap, long enough to eat upstairs at 6 and go downstairs for a cocktail at 7:30. Holiday weeks can bring changed hours, so check both businesses' pages before you go over Thanksgiving weekend.

Thanksgiving weekend at 5601 N. High

Fired Up's regular schedule makes Friday and Saturday its longest days of the week, which puts the two days after Thanksgiving among its fullest. A few ways the building fits the long weekend:

  1. Friday lunch. Fired Up opens at 11 a.m., and a sandwich and a filled-to-order cannoli is an easy midday stop if you're out with family.
  2. Friday or Saturday night. Order pizzas upstairs between 5 and 7 p.m., then head down to The Nine for the cocktail list and a plate of cornbread or tuna crudo.
  3. Sunday. Fired Up is closed, so if guests are still in town, The Nine is the only half of the building open, starting at 5 p.m.

If you knew this address as Natalie's, the floor plan is the same, with food upstairs and a smaller room for drinks downstairs. Our earlier post on Wolf's Ridge at the old Worthington Inn covers the evening options near the Village Green, and our Worthington neighborhood page has more on the rest of the city.

At The Oracle Group, we like knowing which Worthington storefronts just got new tenants, and which nights they're open. If you're thinking about a home within an easy drive of North High Street and want someone who knows what's open on which nights, reach out to our team and Start Your Home Journey with us.

Partner With Our Expert Team

We pride ourselves in providing personalized solutions that bring our clients closer to their dream properties and enhance their long-term wealth. Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!

Follow Us on Instagram